I have been thinking a lot about the words we use. And writing on this can barely touch the surface so these are just a few thoughts about a much bigger picture.
We can never get it right with language. It is so complex and complicated and we can never really know the meaning of certain words to people that we are talking to. A simple word to one person can be a horrific trigger to another. One person may find a term they prefer to use to describe themselves, another may hate it and find it offensive. So, all we can do is be tentative and follow people’s lead on words that are and are not ok. We will almost certainly get it wrong at time, but how we repair the getting it wrong will be the thing that will lead someone to stay or to walk away.
So, three language things that have come up recently. The first is the use of the word resistant. There is a psychotherapist whose writing and teaching I am fond of and she used the word resistant to talk about clients who are finding counselling difficult because they are traumatised. And I have heard the word used, including about myself, and I hadn’t really thought anything of it. And then I saw someone online asking for the word not to be used because it is not a fair description. And I am so torn about this. Traumatised clients are often resistant, I am often resistant… but it’s not down to a negative connotation of the word. They are just doing whatever they can to protect themselves because they have been so hurt that letting someone in and someone to get close feels like it’s way too much. I was being resistant because I was protecting myself. And in counselling training and CPD I have heard the word resistant so often, I was no longer thinking about it, and it wasn’t until someone else said something about it that I even considered this. And then I was trying to think of other words that are used, such as being difficult. Of course traumatised people are being difficult, they are doing their best to keep going, keep surviving, keep protecting themselves. Sometimes even the word protection annoys me though. It leads me to a picture of myself with all these high walls around me letting no one in, because that’s what I have had to do for protection, but using that word doesn’t change what I am doing, and it doesn’t fully explain the resist part. Because, whether my walls are there or not, there are still a number of other reasons of why I haven’t engaged and why I am being resistant. The problem is, the more I have been thinking about it, the more I come to think it is the wrong word to describe the correct thing.
Another word I seem to have a problem with is the word disclosure. And I couldn’t tell you why, it just sits weird inside of me. And yet it is a word used so often to describe when someone has disclosed something about their life, because what other word do you use. I have heard the word story used many times in counselling contexts. And talking of someone’s story can bring out the wrong ideas. Stories are make-belief and made up, whereas we are talking about real life, real things that have happened to people. But I feel like I want to shudder every time I hear the word disclosure. But there is not a word that fits to me. People tell me their lives, they tell me the big things and the little things, they tell me what’s important to them, and they keep talking to keep me away from things. There is not one word that can be used to explain this, but we want to wrap it up neatly in a word to describe it, and it just feels like it’s not possible.
My final one for now is using the terms victim/survivor to talk about people, and this happens in my non-counselling job far more than anything else. Again, some people identify with the words, some identify with other words, and again in this case I would always say to go with whatever the person feels comfortable with. And people will change what they feel comfortable with depending on where they are on their journey. It is not this that I have the issue with. My issue is that it becomes the ones description word we use for that person. I feel like they use their person-ness and become nothing but a survivor. My experience of trauma is that is does take over your entire life, it does in many ways completely define who you are, you can’t ever escape from it, it becomes everything. But, at the same time, I don’t want it to be everything. I still want my life, I still want to be more than what happened to me. So constantly being defined as a survivor, it puts my back in the box that what happened to me is all that my life is. I am a survivor, but I am so much more than that even though most of the time it doesn’t feel like it. I am a person who has survived some horrible things, but I am more than those things.